Aquarist Classifieds
Home Adverts Recent Added Auction Scam Alerts Forum List Your Ad ShopAds Videos Directory
Tropical Fish Aquariums & Equip Marine Fish & Marine Inverts Cichlids Malawi Tanganyikan Cichlids
Wanted Discus Goldfish, Koi & Ponds Retailers & Services ALL ADS By County


New forum at Aquarist Classifieds

   Home  
spacer
   Reply  
  Viewed: 340 -- Replies: 21

PM | All Topics | General | Cichlids | Marine | Coldwater | Tanks/Equipment | Diseases | Members
spacer
Posted NITRATE TEST KITS
30-07-2006
22:35 by Lexter
have to have a moan now....

NUTRAFIN Nitrate Kit, what a JOKE!!!! the colour chart is ridiculous, the colours for 20mg/l, 50mg/l and 100mg/l are virtually the same colours, especially the 50 and 100 that are SAME COLOUR i tell you.

Now, i know your nitrate should really always be below 50, and preferrably 12.5-25 BUT whats the point in selling a test kit where ultimately you Have NO IDEA what the result is??? Especially when it costs £8.99, you may as well take a wild guess if the reading is 20mg/l or over, coz the chart aint gonna help you!!!!

I then bought a Tetra Test Nitrate kit which cost me £11.99 for 45 tests, ridiculous price, 26p a test, so nearly costing me £2 to check my 6 set-ups and tapwater.

BUT, its definitly more accurate than NutraFin, for one they actually bothered to make the colours above 12.5 mg/l DIFFERENT....

Also i tested on the Tetra test and had one tank at 50mg/l and one at 25mg/l (or just below)

When i did it on the Nutrafin one, same colour i.e. same level of Nitrate in both tanks??? Now for me the difference between 25 and 50 is very important!!!

I know lots of test kits are not that accurate anyway

ANYONE KNOW OF THE THE MOST ACCURATE OR WHERE I CAN GET A DIGITAL METHOD AND PROPER READING OF WATER FROM (WITHOUT GOING TO SHOP FOR THE PRIVELEDGE) - thanks
30-07-2006
22:45 by heros hero
hey good buddy, quality rant!!! Are these the dip tests you're using? Great for a ball park result but absolutely pants for an accurate measure.Gotta use the liquid tests for a decent answer. You cutting those strips in half lenghtways to double your money?
30-07-2006
22:48 by Lexter
Hello my dear Heros

these are liquid ones mate, i never use test srips, i think they would make wanna rant even more
30-07-2006
22:51 by KOBISKYE
you could try ebay, i will now, and let you know
30-07-2006
22:51 by Lexter
thats my friend Kobiskye, let us know, think i will take a look now myself
30-07-2006
22:52 by heros hero
Found with the liquid tests that after you've given the bottle a shake, you need to shake it some more before adding to the test tube of water.Shaking the snot out of it was how an american chap described it to me!
30-07-2006
22:54 by KOBISKYE
they all seem to be ph only
30-07-2006
22:54 by Lexter
do you do many water tests Hero???

what set ups you got these days my friend??? I bought some Spirillum (spelling?) cichlids the other day, youngsters, are Cyrptopheros (spelling?) family, beauties, £1.95 for three young ones, about 1 inch big, look like a mix of Severum and Sajica they do mate,
30-07-2006
22:56 by KOBISKYE
i must admit i very rarely use these test kits, scottish water is the best though lol
30-07-2006
22:56 by Lexter
pH winds me up to Kobiskye, the colours are the same, yuo can only get "ball park" figure, i.e. acid or alkaline or "neutral ish"

you would not be able to tell if it is 7.5 or 8 or 8 or 8.5

and i think for every difference (i.e. 7.0 or 8.0) is MASSIVE, if my science is correct, 8.0 is 100 TIMES more alkaline than 7.0 ???
30-07-2006
22:57 by Lexter
Kobisky how much to post 100 litres of your Scottish Water?
30-07-2006
22:58 by KOBISKYE
do u have a long hose
30-07-2006
23:00 by Lexter
not massively long, but i know how to use it
30-07-2006
23:01 by KOBISKYE
lol
30-07-2006
23:05 by heros hero
Lexter, you still the king of quick typing!!! Is not often that i test my water, only if i see the fish acting odd. Water comes out the tap with about 10ppm nitrates so water changes are never really a problem,even with the discus.Your spirulum (spelling!) are same family as cons aren't they? Just better behaved!Trade name jade eye?
30-07-2006
23:25 by Lexter
yes Jade Eye, just looked it up,

cant find much about them?
30-07-2006
23:40 by heros hero
Same behavior as sajica i believe, in which case cave spawners with brilliant fry care. My good friend, you gonna love em.
31-07-2006
00:04 by deejdave
NUTRAFIN anything is a joke mate, I de-stocked it as soon as i took over my last fish shop lol
31-07-2006
00:05 by Lexter
what other Nutrafin products were you unhappy with???

I dont mind their ammonia tester, quite simple and reliable i found,
31-07-2006
00:09 by deejdave
Their foods, their treatments, their testkits... lol.. its all just a bit too cheap and cheerful... ok for goldfish and just mixed trops but wouldnt rely on any of it for africans, marines or specialist breeding set ups.
01-09-2006
11:56 by bluboy
i had some interpet easytests. the ammonia tests and nitrite tests were ok but the ph and nitrate were ***. on the color card my ph didnt show up as any of the colors they show and the nitrate i had the same prob as lexter. theyre all the same above 50!
01-09-2006
15:24 by Danny Boy
i know a stingray keeper that had a tetra safe test kit. it was about 10 yrs old but was a good kit. he would buy the replacement bottles to top it up when needed to keep it all going. one day he tested the water and it was way off so he messed with the chemistry to accomodate the test results and it turned out they had chnged the colours around so the kit was no longer any use. he lost £800 worth of rays in one week. after a lengthy debate he got refunded the cost and the product was removed.
spacer


NEW REPLIES ARE NOW CLOSED ON THIS FORUM

We invite you to join the NEW Aquarist Classifieds Fishkeeping Forum HERE


Your contributions to this forum are greatly appreciated.
This forum will be retained in archive status for reference.





Previous | Fish Biz | Sitemap | Links | Clubs | Webmaster | Our Sponsors | ShopAds | Directory Visits
Aquarist Classifieds

Enquire About Sponsorship
Enquire About Banners

Frozen Beefheart Food








Admin Ref: Aquarist Fishkeeping Forum > NITRATE TEST KITS