Aquarist Classifieds
Home Adverts Recent Added Auction Scam Alerts Fishkeeping Forum List Your Ad ShopAds Videos
Tropical Fish Aquariums & Equip Marine Fish & Marine Inverts Cichlids Malawi Tanganyikan Cichlids
Wanted Discus Goldfish, Koi & Ponds Retailers & Services ALL ADS By County


New forum at Aquarist Classifieds

   Home  
spacer
   Reply  
  Viewed: 650 -- Replies: 16

PM | All Topics | General | Cichlids | Marine | Coldwater | Tanks/Equipment | Diseases | Members
spacer
Posted BIO BALLS sump filter
28-02-2007
21:32 by SomethingFishy
I am updating my sump to 110 gallon, i am currently using ceramic media and filter wool.

Can i please ask what peoples views are on how effective bio balls are, average price to pay and any recomended sellers.

Thanks in advance.
28-02-2007
21:47 by wymcot
You would be far better using something like alfragrog as it has a far greater surface area than bioballs and subsequently can accomodate a far greater population of bacteria
28-02-2007
22:00 by SomethingFishy
where is a good place to buy it from
i have seen it being used in koi ponds etc but never seen it for sale
28-02-2007
22:05 by Flying saucer owner
Bio balls are much more efficient than alfagrog. They are self cleaning where as after a while alfragrog becomes clogged with detritus which decreases its effectiveness & it starts to pong
28-02-2007
22:19 by wymcot
Obviously personal choice but I have never had alfagrog clog up and I have been using it for years.


Bioballs are great in large quantities, say in a trickle filter, but for bog standard externals you just cant get enough in there.
28-02-2007
22:21 by wayne
yes but if you give it a good rinse /shake in the aquarium water its as good as new , i use alfagrog in all my filters , bio balls are well over priced and over rated , even flocor is miles cheaper
28-02-2007
22:46 by SomethingFishy
Where is the best place to source alfragrog and what should i expect to pay for it ? thanks
28-02-2007
22:48 by Flying saucer owner
'Bioballs are great in large quantities, say in a trickle filter, but for bog standard externals you just cant get enough in there'
Yes they are not meant for external filters but SomethingFishy wants to use them in a sump.
28-02-2007
22:59 by Flying saucer owner
'yes but if you give it a good rinse /shake in the aquarium water its as good as new , i use alfagrog in all my filters , bio balls are well over priced and over rated , even flocor is miles cheaper'

Depends on the size of the sump & the fish that hes keeping. If he is using a large sump with some sort of ceramic/porous media to filter the waste of large fish, cleaning the media will soon become a chore.
28-02-2007
23:07 by wymcot
I obviously missed the sump bit
28-02-2007
23:16 by wayne
go with what works for you >
28-02-2007
23:48 by paul stevens
Yeah just go and buy some of each save all the banter mind you we like a bit of banter in here aint been any for awhile...
01-03-2007
09:40 by Alan
Is this freshwater or marine?
01-03-2007
10:23 by SomethingFishy
It is freshwater and i have the sump setup as in the pic
01-03-2007
10:54 by SomethingFishy
I guess i should add the full setup info.

It is to filter 10 tanks from 2x 4 foot 5x 3foot and 3x 18" cubes

The bio load is
1x 9" coral butterfly
6x 4-6" Giraffe Haps
2x 4" Flame mouths
1x 3" Dubosi (Asbo as he is known in the family right trouble maker but loves being with the haps)
2x 8" Long neck soft shell turtles
30x 1" rummy nose
1x Melonacromis Aurotis (Rambo)

The pump is an industrial sump pump and can do 600 gal per hour.

Thanks Something Fishy
01-03-2007
11:19 by Alan
Fill it with alfa grog you can get a 20lb back for about a tenner normally from koi specialist outlets you will probably need to break it up a bit.

Great for big polluters as it does not clog in the same way as cintered glass does.
01-03-2007
11:21 by Alan
Bio balls are good but they have never impressed me when used on koi ponds I have always thought there must be something better.

As far as cleaning it goes just oyck it out every couple of months and give it a good clean in a large bucket of tank water in fact a better option would be to do the chambers alternately on a 3 week cycle.
spacer


NEW REPLIES ARE NOW CLOSED ON THIS FORUM

We invite you to join the NEW Aquarist Classifieds Fishkeeping Forum HERE


Your contributions to this forum are greatly appreciated.
This forum will be retained in archive status for reference.





Previous | Fish Biz | Sitemap | Links | All Ads | Clubs | Webmaster | Our Sponsors | ShopAds Visits
Aquarist Classifieds

Enquire About Sponsorship
Enquire About Banners

Frozen Beefheart Food








Admin Ref: Aquarist Fishkeeping Forum > BIO BALLS sump filter